What is the difference between stock options and employee stock ownership plans?

In our last post we found out what Employee Stock Options are. Today we will dissect an Employee Stock Option Plan, what it’s made of, how to make one, and some tips and tricks for founders on the way. Let’s get into it.

An Employee Stock Option Plan is a contract between employee and employer that grants stock options. In other words, employees have a right to purchase the company shares at a set price over set a time window.

Please note that we used the term Employee Stock Option Plan, as opposed to Employee Share Ownership Plan.

What is the difference between an Employee Stock Option Plan vs. Employee Stock Ownership Plan?

*Note: Employee Stock Ownership Plan is not necessarily the same thing as Employee Stock Option Plan. Employee Stock Ownership Plan is a retirement plan where an employer contributes its company stock to the benefit plan of an employee. Employee Stock Option Plan can be seen as a type of Employee Stock Ownership Plan.

(Source: U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission)

1. ESOP Agreement

We learned last time that Employee Stock Options are not the actual share ownership. Employee Stock Options are the rights granted to employees. These rights must first be brought into existence. This is why your company first needs to create a thoughtfully written ESOP agreement.

“Let there be Employee Stock Options.” - ESOP

Now that you have brought your company’s Employee Stock Options to existence,  you want to start thinking about where to put them.

2. ESOP Pool

What is the difference between stock options and employee stock ownership plans?

You have to create an ESOP pool for your company that will set aside a pre-determined % of equity shareholding for your employees. In general, companies set aside about 10-15% of their employee stock options for employees.

In order to keep everyone happy, you want to make a prudent decision on how much to set aside for the board and for the rest of employees.

3. ESOP Committee

Now that we have a vast pool of Employee Stock Options wading and floundering unsupervised, we need someone to manage this pool before they drown.

An ESOP agreement should also set the details of an ESOP Committee.

An ESOP committee is responsible for managing the ESOP pool and recommending necessary actions to the Board of Directors. ESOP committee is generally made up of company’s directors and officers. So now we have some lifeguards keeping an eye on our children (stock options) in the pool.

4. Cliff & Vesting Period

May skip if you have already read our last post on Employee Stock Options.

What is a Cliff?

An Employee Stock Option Plan could have a cliff and a vesting period per ESOP.

Employee Stock Options are generally given over a period of time, and not all at once. This distribution of stock options over time is called vesting, which means employees will earn their share over a period of time. Vesting encourages employees to stick around longer and perform better.

Cliff is a time period within which no vesting can occur. It refers to the time period before an employee can receive the first promised portion of the stock.

During the cliff, no stock options are vested. If options are not vested, employees cannot exercise them. To exercise stock options means to buy a set number of stock options at a set price — called exercise price, or strike price —  that is lower than the market price.

When the cliff hits, the employee can exercise the first portion of the promised benefit.

If employee resigns during the Cliff period, they will NOT receive any stock options. It is important to set these arrangements clearly in the stock option agreement. A typical cliff period for startups is one year.

What is the difference between stock options and employee stock ownership plans?
4-Year Vesting Period with 1 Year Cliff

What is a Vesting Period?

We saw that stock options are vested, and employees have to work to earn their share of an asset. The number of options an employee can exercise increases over time on a schedule, called a vesting schedule.

Vesting period is a period of time before all ESOP shares become fully, and unconditionally owned by employee.

In the graph above, the cliff lasts for a year, and the vesting period lasts for four years.

If the employee resigns during the vesting period (usually after the Cliff), they will be given pro-rated stock options based on the length of employment.

FYI for Startups in Singapore 🇸🇬 : Selling Restriction

What is a selling restriction?

In Singapore, you can include a selling restriction, which is a period of time where an employee is not allowed to sell their shares.

Selling restrictions will affect how gains from ESOP plans are taxed for employees, so be sure to research or receive proper consulting on whether and how to set this selling restriction.

So now you understand why it is important to create and manage ESOP for your employees and your company’s growth, but with so many employees coming and going, managing everything manually could easily be a recipe for a disaster.

On QuotaBook, you can create different types of Employee Stock Option plans, letting you digitalize the entire process at just one click.

Manage Several Option Plans

What is the difference between stock options and employee stock ownership plans?

Make & Manage Vesting Schedules

What is the difference between stock options and employee stock ownership plans?
What is the difference between stock options and employee stock ownership plans?

Grant Stock Options

What is the difference between stock options and employee stock ownership plans?
What is the difference between stock options and employee stock ownership plans?

QuotaBook helps you manage efficiently and accurately, so you can solely focus on growth. QuotaBook is trusted by 2000+ startups and VCs, and our onboarding team consisted of experienced professionals here to guide you through the process.

More Questions? Click 👇

What is the difference between stock options and employee stock ownership plans?

Start now, Get 3 Months Free Trial.

References:

https://uk.practicallaw.thomsonreuters.com/Document/Ia294f3b7060011ecbea4f0dc9fb69570/View/FullText.html?contextData=(sc.Default)&transitionType=Default

https://singaporelegaladvice.com/law-articles/preparing-employee-stock-option-plan-esop-singapore/

https://sleek.com/sg/resources/a-beginners-guide-to-esops-in-singapore/

https://sbr.com.sg/financial-services/commentary/basics-employee-share-option-plans-esops-in-singapore

https://www.iras.gov.sg/taxes/individual-income-tax/basics-of-individual-income-tax/what-is-taxable-what-is-not/employment-income/gains-from-the-exercise-of-stock-options

Make equity simple with QuotaBook — QuotaBook is a global equity management platform with a mission to create an ecosystem for private companies and their investors and employees. Leaving spreadsheets and manual works behind, every stakeholder can connect online and sync crucial data on equity such as cap table or employee stock options. It is the leading platform used by top startups and VCs in Asia, backed by Y Combinator.

Disclaimer: This piece is written for information purposes only and is not intended as financial or legal advice. QuotaBook does not assume any reliability for dependence on the information provided above.

What is the difference between stock options and an employee stock ownership plan?

Identification. An ESOP qualifies as a retirement plan, such as a 401 (k) or individual retirement account, while corporations use stock options as an employee benefit, like health insurance. In an ESOP, the company contributes to employee retirement plans with its own stock.

What is the difference between stock options and an employee stock ownership plan quizlet?

Stock options are usually granted to company executives whereas ESOP's are provided to all employees.

Is a stock option plan an ESOP?

An employee stock ownership plan (ESOP) is an IRC section 401(a) qualified defined contribution plan that is a stock bonus plan or a stock bonus/money purchase plan.

What is the difference between a stock bonus plan and an ESOP?

Also, only ESOPs can borrow money on the credit of the company to buy employer stock. Stock bonus and profit sharing plans have somewhat less restrictive rules than ESOPs, however, particularly around distribution requirements, valuation requirements, and what percentage of assets must be held in company stock.